Hong Kong Med J 2015 Feb;21(1):38–44 | Epub 21 Nov 2014
Role of fine-needle aspiration cytology in human immunodeficiency virus–associated lymphadenopathy: a cross-sectional study from northern India
Naveen Kumar, MD1; BB Gupta, MD1; Brijesh Sharma, MD1; Manju Kaushal, MD2; BB Rewari, MD1; Deepak Sundriyal, MD1
1 Department of Medicine, PGIMER and Dr RML Hospital, New Delhi 110001, India
2 Department of Pathology, PGIMER and Dr RML Hospital, New Delhi 110001, India
Objective: To evaluate the role of fine-needle aspiration cytology in the diagnosis of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)–associated lymphadenopathy.
Design: Case series.
Setting: Tertiary care teaching hospital, India.
Patients: Fifty consecutive HIV-positive patients, who presented with lymphadenopathy at the out-patient department and antiretroviral therapy clinic.
Results: Tubercular lymphadenitis was the most common diagnosis, reported in 74% (n=37) of patients; 97.2% of them were acid-fast bacilli–positive. Reactive lymphadenitis and fungal lymphadenitis were present in 10 and 1 cases, respectively. The most common cytomorphological pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis was necrotising suppurative lymphadenitis, present in 43.2% (n=16) of patients. Of eight biopsies done in reactive cases, six turned out to be tubercular lymphadenitis. Fine-needle aspiration cytology had a sensitivity of 83.7% for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis.
Conclusion: Necrotising suppurative lymphadenitis should be recognised as an established pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis. Reactive patterns should be considered inconclusive rather than a negative result, and re-evaluated with lymph node biopsy. Fine-needle aspiration cytology is an excellent test for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis in HIV-associated lymphadenopathy.
New knowledge added by this study
- Necrotising suppurative lymphadenitis should be recognised as an established pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis.
- In advanced human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) disease, reactive lymphadenitis should be considered inconclusive rather than a negative result, and re-evaluated with lymph node biopsy.
- As lymphadenopathy is common in all stages of HIV disease, judicious use of fine-needle aspiration cytology can be helpful in diagnosing associated opportunistic infections and other pathological conditions.
Human immunodeficiency virus (HIV) infection is an important worldwide public health problem. Developing nations, where resources are limited, are the worst affected nations. Until curative treatment for HIV infection becomes available, the crux of management is early diagnosis and treatment with highly active antiretroviral therapy.
As HIV is a lymphotropic virus, lymphoid tissues are the major anatomical site where the virus establishes itself during early infection. These lymphoid tissues act as reservoirs for the virus in the asymptomatic phase of infection. In the late stage, HIV disseminates from these sites to cause a full-blown acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS).1 Thus, lymph node involvement is found in all stages of infection. The cause of lymph node enlargement is often difficult to establish by history, physical examination, radiographic studies, and routine laboratory tests. Surgical biopsy is the gold standard for diagnosis. However, it has several drawbacks: costly, time-consuming, and requiring more elaborate precautions. Fine-needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) does not have any of these limitations, and is also comparatively less invasive. Furthermore, the cost of aspiration cytology is only 10% to 30% of that of surgical biopsy.2
We performed FNAC to establish the aetiological diagnosis in our study subjects with HIV infection. To detect false-negative results, biopsy was done in cases diagnosed as reactive lymphadenitis. The aims of the study were to assess the accuracy of FNAC and to correlate the findings with clinical and laboratory parameters like CD4 counts.
The study was conducted in the Departments of Medicine and Pathology, PGIMER and Dr RML Hospital, New Delhi, India, from January 2009 to December 2009. The study protocol and proforma were approved by the ethics committee of the institute. Informed written consent was obtained from all patients. Fine-needle aspiration cytology was performed in 50 consecutive HIV-positive patients presenting with lymphadenopathy at the antiretroviral clinic, or the out-patient or in-patient services. Detailed history was taken and examination of the patients was performed. Clinical stage (as per the World Health Organization [WHO] classification) and CD4 counts were recorded for all patients. Fine-needle aspiration cytology was performed by the clinician on the largest non-inguinal lymph node using standard precautions. The area was cleaned and draped. A 10-mL syringe and 23-gauge needles were used. If the sample was insufficient, another sample was taken from a different lymph node. Slides for Papanicolaou and Periodic-acid Schiff (PAS) stains were fixed with 95% ethanol immediately after preparing the smear; others were air dried. A total of six slides were prepared from each aspirate and were immediately processed by staining with Giemsa stain, Papanicolaou’s stain, Ziehl-Neelsen (ZN) stain for acid-fast bacilli (AFB), PAS stain for fungi, and Gram stain. Cases that were AFB-positive on ZN staining were diagnosed as tubercular lymphadenitis; otherwise, they were retained as suspected cases. Based on the presence or absence of granulomas, caseation (necrosis) and neutrophilic infiltration, tubercular lymph nodes were classified into four cytomorphological categories: granulomatous lymphadenitis (GL), necrotising granulomatous lymphadenitis (NGL), necrotising lymphadenitis (NL), and necrotising suppurative lymphadenitis (NSL). Lymph node biopsies were performed in cases which showed a reactive pattern or suspected tubercular lymphadenitis on FNAC. Sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values were calculated for FNAC as a diagnostic modality compared with biopsy. Statistical analysis for association between FNAC findings and various parameters was done using univariate and multivariate logistic regression analyses. Data analysis was performed by the Statistical Package for the Social Sciences (Windows version 19.0; SPSS Inc, Chicago [IL], US). A P value of less than 0.05 was regarded as statistically significant.
A total of 50 patients (43 men and 7 women) were included in the study. The mean age of the patients was 32.4 years. Cervical region was the most common site of lymphadenopathy (n=39; 78%) followed by axillary and inguinal regions. The lymph nodes were matted and generalised in 62% (n=31) and 48% (n=24) of cases, respectively. Generalised lymphadenopathy was present in 54% (n=20) of cases with tubercular lymphadenitis and 40% (n=4) of cases with reactive lymphadenitis. Nature of aspirate was bloody in 21 (42%) cases, caseous in 24 (48%), and mixed (with blood and caseation) in the remaining patients. The CD4 count ranged from 12 cells/µL to 353 cells/µL, with a mean count of 131 cells/µL. Most of the patients were in WHO clinical stage 3 (n=31; 62%).
The most common cytological diagnosis was tubercular lymphadenitis (n=37; 74%) followed by reactive pattern (n=10; 20%). Only one FNAC was diagnosed as fungal lymphadenitis showing PAS-positive spores of Histoplasma capsulatum (Fig 1). In two cases, the cytologies were suggestive of thyroid tissue and lipoma; these were treated as failed FNACs. Tubercular lymphadenitis was further categorised into four cytomorphological patterns, as shown in Table 1. All tubercular cases were AFB-positive except one which was a AFB-negative GL on FNAC. Subsequently, this was shown to be AFB-positive tubercular lymphadenitis on biopsy. Of the 10 cases reported as reactive lymph nodes on FNAC, eight gave consent for biopsy. Biopsy showed AFB-positive fibrocaseous tubercular lymphadenopathy in six out of these eight cases; in the remaining two cases, biopsy findings matched with the FNAC findings.
Figure 1. Histoplasma lymphadenitis: Periodic-acid Schiff–positive oval yeast cells with thick capsule (white arrow), both extracellular and intracellular (black arrow heads) in location (x 100)
All cases diagnosed as having mycobacterial disease on FNAC and those who underwent biopsy were included in the analysis. Hence 45 cases were analysed: 36 cases diagnosed as mycobacterial (tubercular) lymphadenitis on FNAC, one case of GL which was AFB-positive fibrocaseous tubercular lymph node on biopsy, and eight cases of reactive lymphadenopathy that underwent biopsy (Table 2). The sensitivity and negative predictive value of FNAC for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis were 83.7% and 22.2%, respectively. As AFB positivity was the requisite criterion for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis, it was expected that there would be no diagnosis of tuberculosis (TB) in any case which was AFB-negative on FNAC; thus, the specificity and positive predictive value were 100%.
We performed logistic regression analysis with tubercular lymphadenitis as the dependent variable and four parameters as covariates. On univariate analysis, CD4 count (P=0.016), nature of aspirate (P=0.013), and matted nodes on examination (P=0.028) were associated with tubercular aetiology on FNAC; lymph node distribution did not show any such association (P=0.401). However, in multivariate analysis, none of these factor was associated with tubercular aetiology on FNAC. Moreover, none of these factors was associated with the severe form (NL or NSL) of tubercular lymphadenitis either on univariate or multivariate analysis.
Lymphadenopathy in HIV patients is very common; it can be a presenting feature in about 35% of patients with AIDS.3 Causes can be varied, depending on the stage of the disease, and may include persistent generalised lymphadenopathy, lymphoid malignancies, and opportunistic infection. All these can be easily and efficiently diagnosed by aspiration study of these lymph nodes. These causes of lymphadenopathies are important causes of death in AIDS patients. In this study, we aimed to investigate the performance of FNAC for the accurate diagnosis of lymphadenopathies. We also compared our results with those from similar Indian and western studies (Table 3 1 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16).
Table 3. Comparison of our FNAC results with those from previous studies1 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16
Tuberculosis is the most frequent opportunistic infection in HIV patients.17 18 Lymph nodes are the commonest site of extra-pulmonary TB in patients with AIDS.19 20 Using FNAC as the diagnostic modality, we also found tubercular lymphadenitis to be the most common cause of lymphadenopathy, present in 74% of our patients. Similar conclusion was drawn in other Indian studies; however they reported a prevalence of 34.2% to 60% (Table 3). The high prevalence of tubercular lymphadenitis in our series may be related to the low immunity of the majority of patients; 41 out of 50 patients had CD4 counts of <200 cells/µL.
There are two specific pathological criteria for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis—caseation and granuloma formation. Both are less likely to be present in tubercular lymphadenitis associated with advanced HIV disease. This is because T-cell function, which is suppressed in advanced HIV disease, is required for granuloma formation. On the basis of these two findings, tubercular lymphadenitis is classified into three categories21 22: GL, NGL, and NL.
The GL pattern can occur due to several causes. However, in a country like India, where TB is very common, this pattern is considered to be due to TB until proven otherwise. We found this pattern in 5.4% (2 out of 37 cases with tubercular lymphadenitis) of TB cases, a finding similar to that in other previous studies where it ranged from 4.3% to 28.5% (Table 4).6 9 11 12 16 23 The NGL pattern, with both caseation and epithelioid granulomas, is the most typical pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis. It was present in 18.9% (7 out 37 cases of tubercular lymphadenitis) of our cases; other studies have reported it in the range of 26.6% to 74% (Table 4).9 11 12 16 23 Necrotising lymphadenitis represents the most severe cytomorphological pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis. There is complete necrosis with only ‘acellular’ debris. It is not labelled as ‘purulent’ because there are no degenerated polymorphonuclear cells. Complete necrosis reflects impaired cell-mediated immunity in this group of patients. Cases of NGL can be wrongly labelled as NL if material is aspirated from that part of the node which contains only caseation. This was the second most common pattern reported in our study (32.4%; 12 out of 37 cases of tubercular lymphadenitis). In other studies, the reported prevalence rates range from 8.6% to 57.1% (Table 4).6 9 11 12 16 23
Table 4. Cytomorphological patterns in tubercular lymphadenitis: comparison with previous studies6 9 11 12 16 23
The NSL pattern of tubercular lymphadenitis (Fig 2) was the most common cytomorphological picture, seen in 43.2% (16 out of 37 cases of tubercular lymphadenitis) of patients. This pattern was reported in 20% and 13% cases of tubercular lymphadenitis by Nayak et al11 and Shenoy et al,12 respectively (Table 4). Jayaram and Chew6 reported this pattern in 67% of their TB cases in Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia. Although reported in these case series, unlike the other three patterns, the NSL pattern is not yet a well-recognised cytomorphological type of tubercular lymphadenitis. However, this pattern is important, especially in HIV patients. If ZN staining is not done, the thin caseation commonly present in these cases can be mistaken for pus, and the case wrongly labelled as pyogenic lymphadenitis. Similar observations have been made in some studies.6 11 12 24
Figure 2. Liquefied necrotic material (black arrow head) with infiltration of polymorphs (white arrow), giving impression of suppurative lymphadenitis. No epithelioid cells or giant cells are seen (Giemsa staining, x 40)
Studies have shown that FNAC is more sensitive for the diagnosis of TB in HIV-positive patients than in seronegative patients.25 In our series, AFB positivity rate in TB cases was 97.2% (n=36/37), which was higher than that in previous studies (43.4% to 95.2%).6 9 11 12 16 This could be due to the fact that the disease was quite advanced in our group of tubercular lymphadenitis patients (mean CD4 count of 108 cells/µL). Moreover, as the cytomorphological pattern deteriorated and necrosis appeared, AFB positivity increased from 50% to 100%. This was in agreement with data from earlier studies.6 9 11 12 16 Chances of detecting AFB were least in lymph nodes showing GL pattern: four out of five studies6 9 11 12 16 did not report any AFB-positive case with this pattern of lymphadenopathy. Further, although TB is very common in HIV subjects, Mycobacterium avium complex (MAC) is not frequently seen in India. Its chance further decreases by adding MAC prophylaxis of azithromycin to the patient’s treatment regimen.
A reactive lymphadenitis was observed in only 20% of cases in our study. Most of the western studies reported it as the most common lymph node pathology, observed in 25.6% to 59.6% of cases (Table 3). One case of histoplasmosis was detected in our study (Fig 1). On Giemsa staining, the lymph node showed reactive lymphoid cells, histiocytes, areas of granuloma formation, along with sheets of Histoplasma capsulatum organism, located both extracellularly and intracellularly, which were positive on PAS staining. Hence, although the finding of GL without AFB in HIV-infected patients in India is taken as TB unless proven otherwise, causes like fungal infection (by PAS staining) should be excluded, especially if the CD4 count is low.
We performed a lymph node biopsy in 18% of our cases (Table 5). Among these, the findings were different from those in FNAC in 77.8% of the cases. False-negative rate in our study was 16.3% (7 out of 43 cases of TB; Table 2). The false-negative rate in other studies ranges from 2% to 9.2%.1 4 7 8 Of these seven false-negative cases, six were diagnosed as reactive nodes on FNAC which later showed fibrocaseous nodes on biopsy. Possible reasons for discordance could be focal tubercular involvement of the nodes. On FNAC, the tubercular area could have been missed and, hence, wrongly labelled as reactive cases. Also, different nodes in the same area can enlarge due to different pathologies. Hence, a report of reactive pattern in advanced disease, like in our group of patients (mean CD4 in reactive group being 196 cells/µL), does not have much value, and should not be the end of further assessment. It should be considered an inconclusive result rather than a negative one. It emphasises the importance of performing a biopsy in this group of patients.
A falling CD4 count in our group of patients was associated with increasing risk of tubercular lymphadenitis. However, CD4 counts did not predict the severity of cytomorphological forms of tubercular lymphadenitis. Of note, 41 out of 50 patients had CD4 counts of <200 cells/µL. Hence, we did not have a group of patients with higher CD4 counts in whom less severe forms of tubercular lymphadenitis were more common. This association should be studied further by recruiting patients with a wide range of CD4 counts.
In univariate analysis, a matted lymph node on examination (P=0.028) and caseous material (P=0.013) on aspiration were found more often in TB cases versus reactive cases. Hence, apart from routine cytology stains, these observations guide us for ordering special staining like ZN staining. However, their association with cytomorphological pattern of TB was not significant on univariate analysis, as the whole spectrum of pattern can have caseation on aspiration (except GL) and matted nodes on examination, although cytomorphologically these are of increasing severity.
Tuberculosis is the most common aetiology of HIV-associated lymphadenopathy in India. Acid-fast bacilli positivity is very high in HIV-associated tubercular lymphadenitis. We recommend routine AFB staining for all lymph nodes undergoing FNAC in HIV patients. Lymph nodes showing AFB-negative GL pattern on FNAC should be stained for fungus, especially if CD4 count is low. If a patient’s CD4 count is low, a reactive FNAC pattern should be taken as an inconclusive result and is an indication for biopsy. All lymph nodes showing NSL pattern on FNAC should undergo ZN staining in HIV-positive patients. It should be recognised as a tubercular cytomorphological pattern, especially in patients with low immunity like those with AIDS. Fine-needle aspiration cytology of lymph nodes is a valuable test for diagnosing tubercular lymphadenitis in HIV-associated lymphadenopathy.
1. Satyanarayana S, Kalighatgi AT, Murlidhar A, Prasad RS, Jawed KZ, Trehan A. Fine needle aspiration cytology of lymph node in HIV infected patients. Medical Journal Armed Forces India 2002;58:33-7. CrossRef
2. Kaminsky DB. Aspiration biopsy for community hospital. In: Johnston WW, editor. Masson monograph in diagnostic cytopathology. New York: Masson Publication; 1981: 12-3.
3. Guidelines for prevention and management of common opportunistic infection/malignancy among HIV-infected adult and adolescents. NACO. Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. Government of India; May 2007.
4. Martin-Bates E, Tanner A, Suvarna SK, Glazer G, Coleman DV. Use of fine needle aspiration cytology for investigating lymphadenopathy in HIV positive patients. J Clin Pathol 1993;46:564-6. CrossRef
5. Shapiro AL, Pincus RL. Fine-needle aspiration of diffuse cervical lymphadenopathy in patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome. Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg 1991;105:419-21.
6. Jayaram G, Chew MT. Fine needle aspiration cytology of lymph nodes in HIV-infected individuals. Acta Cytol 2000;44:960-6. CrossRef
7. Reid AJ, Miller RF, Kocjan GI. Diagnostic utility of fine needle aspiration (FNA) cytology in HIV-infected patients with lymphadenopathy. Cytopathology 1998;9:230-9. CrossRef
8. Bottles K, McPhaul LW, Volberding P. Fine-needle aspiration biopsy of patients with acquired immunodeficiency syndrome (AIDS): experience in an outpatient clinic. Ann Intern Med 1988;108:42-5. CrossRef
9. Llatjos M, Romeu J, Clotet B, et al. A distinctive cytologic pattern for diagnosing tuberculous lymphadenitis in AIDS. J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr 1993;6:1335-8.
10. Lowe SM, Kocjan GI, Edwards SG, Miller RF. Diagnostic yield of fine-needle aspiration cytology in HIV-infected patients with lymphadenopathy in the era of highly active antiretroviral therapy. Int J STD AIDS 2008;19:553-6. CrossRef
11. Nayak S, Mani R, Kavatkar AN, Puranik SC, Holla VV. Fine-needle aspiration cytology in lymphadenopathy of HIV-positive patients. Diagn Cytopathol 2003;29:146-8. CrossRef
12. Shenoy R, Kapadi SN, Pai KP, et al. Fine needle aspiration diagnosis in HIV related lymphadenopathy in Mangalore, India. Acta Cytol 2002;46:35-9. CrossRef
13. Saikia UN, Dey P, Jindal B, Saikia B. Fine needle aspiration cytology in lymphadenopathy of HIV-positive cases. Acta Cytol 2001;45:589-92. CrossRef
14. Gill PS, Arora DR, Arora B, et al. Lymphadenopathy. An important guiding tool for detecting hidden HIV-positive cases: a 6-year study. J Int Assoc Physicians AIDS Care (Chic) 2007;6:269-72. CrossRef
15. Shobhana A, Guha SK, Mitra K, Dasgupta A, Neogi DK, Hazra SC. People living with HIV infection / AIDS—a study on lymph node FNAC and CD4 count. Indian J Med Microbiol 2002;20:99-101.
16. Vanisri HR, Nandini NM, Sunila R. Fine-needle aspiration cytology findings in human immunodeficiency virus lymphadenopathy. Indian J Pathol Microbiol 2008;51:481-4. CrossRef
17. Harries AD. Tuberculosis and human immunodeficiency virus infection in developing countries. Lancet 1990;335:387-90. CrossRef
18. Sharma SK, Kadhiravan T, Banga A, Goyal T, Bhatia I, Saha PK. Spectrum of clinical disease in a series of 135 hospitalised HIV-infected patients from north India. BMC Infect Dis 2004;4:52. CrossRef
19. Shafer RW, Kim DS, Weiss JP, Quale JM. Extrapulmonary tuberculosis in patients with human immunodeficiency virus infection. Medicine (Baltimore) 1991;70:384-97. CrossRef
20. Arora VK, Kumar SV. Pattern of opportunistic pulmonary infections in HIV sero-positive subjects: observations from Pondicherry, India. Indian J Chest Dis Allied Sci 1999;41:135-44.
21. Das DK, Pant JN, Chachra KL, et al. Tuberculous lymphadenitis: correlation of cellular components and necrosis in lymph-node aspirate with A.F.B. positivity and bacillary count. Indian J Pathol Microbiol 1990;33:1-10.
22. Das DK. Fine needle aspiration cytology in diagnosis of tuberculous lesion. Lab Med 2000;31:625-32. CrossRef
23. Rajasekaran S, Gunasekaran M, Jayakumar DD, et al. Tuberculous cervical lymphadenitis in HIV positive and negative patients. Indian J Tuberc 2001;48:201-4.
24. Havlir DV, Barnes PF. Tuberculosis in patients with human immunodeficiency virus infection. N Engl J Med 1999;340:367-73. CrossRef
25. Shriner KA, Mathisen GE, Goetz MB. Comparison of mycobacterial lymphadenitis among persons infected with human immunodeficiency virus and seronegative controls. Clin Infect Dis 1992;15:601-5. CrossRef
Find HKMJ in MEDLINE: